By Rabbi Micah Greenland
NCSY International Director
Dear NCSY Family,
Parshas Noach presents us with a difficult question.
Noach experienced one of the most extraordinary demonstrations of Hashem’s direct involvement in human history. While the rest of his generation was destroyed by the Mabul, Hashem personally ensured the survival of Noach and his family, entrusting them with the future of humanity.
When Noach emerged from the teivah, his first act was to build an altar and bring sacrifices to Hashem in gratitude.
Yet almost immediately afterward, the Torah tells us that Noach planted a vineyard, became intoxicated, and found himself at the center of a deeply troubling episode involving his family.
How could someone who had just experienced such an extraordinary revelation of Hashem’s presence fall so far, so quickly?
Perhaps the answer can be found in a familiar moment from our own spiritual calendar.
At the conclusion of Neilah, the final prayer of Yom Kippur, we reach what is arguably the spiritual high point of the entire year. We proclaim “Hashem Hu HaElokim” seven times, followed by “L’Shanah Haba’ah B’Yerushalayim“, affirming that Hashem is our God and expressing our hope to return to Jerusalem in the coming year.
And then, almost immediately, we recite “V’hu Rachum Yechaper Avon,” asking Hashem to forgive our sins.
What are we asking forgiveness for? We just finished Neilah. We haven’t even left shul yet. What did we do wrong?
It is a natural human tendency that the moment we take our accomplishments for granted can be the very moment we become most vulnerable to losing them. After an intense spiritual experience, we are tempted to breathe a sigh of relief. We have reached a high point, and now we can relax, let our guard down, and return to our ordinary routines. We forget that spiritual growth does not sustain itself automatically, but rather is something we have to work on every day.
Perhaps that is why we ask for forgiveness immediately after Neilah. Even the temptation to let our spiritual guard down is something we need to recognize and address.
Noach made a similar mistake. After witnessing Hashem’s extraordinary protection and emerging from the teivah with a profound sense of gratitude, he allowed himself to breathe that sigh of relief. Rather than continuing to nurture that spiritual connection, he let his guard down, with devastating consequences.
It is a particularly relevant lesson as we emerge from the high holiday season.
We have spent weeks immersed in prayer, repentance, and meaningful Jewish experiences. But the real measure of those experiences is not simply how inspired we felt in the moment. It is what we do with that inspiration afterward.
This idea is also central to our work at NCSY and JSU
A powerful Shabbaton, a transformative summer in Israel, or an inspiring conversation with an advisor can open the door to tremendous spiritual growth. But we know that the experience itself is only the beginning.
That is why we place such an emphasis on the relationships and continued engagement that follow. Through ongoing mentorship, consistent programming, and opportunities to take the next step in their Jewish journeys, we help teens build on moments of inspiration rather than allowing them to fade.
Parshas Noach reminds us that spiritual growth has to be a constant avodah, an ongoing effort. Reaching a spiritual high point is an accomplishment, but sustaining it requires us to continue working at it.